tasmania.wtf

The live register

Who can actually say no?

Fifteen decisions that are still open. Each names the instrument, the person or body who can change it, and what closes when they do.

The question in a project like this is usually put as “will it be approved?” That is the wrong question. Approval is one decision among fifteen, and most of the others are made by bodies that never appear in a planning report: a generator board, a network business, a regulator, a treasurer.

A decision is worth watching when three things are true — it is still open, one identifiable person or body can close it, and closing it forecloses something that cannot be recovered later. Everything else is commentary.

The register

#Decision or instrumentWho can change itStatus and windowCloses into
1 Hydro's long-term supply determination for 444 MW S89 Hydro Tasmania board Not decided. An outcome expected by the end of 2026 S89; the request reached the board after the chief executive's delegation was crossed S83. 444 MW priced, or not, for the life of the contract
2 Connection contracting: Asset Development Agreement and Customer Connection Agreement S125 TasNetworks board Pre-financial close; no agreement announced S4. Capacity and security fixed at the connection point
3 Treasurer's business-case exception for St Leonards S79 Treasurer Recommendation redacted; outcome not established. The threshold test is spent either way
4 AEMC cost-recovery and prudential rule changes S110 AEMC board Draft determination due 1 April 2027 S110. National terms set for the next decade
5 First project agreement under the 13 November Expectations S86 Minister for Energy, then the proponent No agreement public; the fund is non-statutory. The expectations are described as binding, but no instrument, enforcement provision, remedy, security or termination right is published. The precedent for every later proponent
6 The five TASCAT appeals, with the EPA joined S55 TASCAT Pending; no determination date. Diesel conditions at Long Reach, or the approval itself
7 GBE Act instruments: s. 13 notification, charter, s. 9A direction, Treasurer's Instructions Treasurer and portfolio minister Unused on the record; no notification disclosed. The only standing lever on counterparty risk
8 Prescribed transmission charges for the northern works, on a ~210 MW trigger AER, on TasNetworks' revenue proposal 2029–34 submission; contingent project not yet triggered. Who pays A$370.6m, and on what basis
9 Water: six proponents' connections with TasWater S132 TasWater, then the relevant council Six requests; development applications being prepared S132. Water allocated before any energy assessment
10 ASIC's inquiries into the failed float S129 ASIC “Yet to launch an official investigation”; engaging with lead managers S129. Whether the capital event is publicly examined at all
11 Wesley Vale 52 MW: staged approvals and any major-project referral Latrobe Council; the Minister for Planning 26 MW approved by delegation S74; second stage pending. A second site with no cumulative condition
12 Allocation of firm energy between competing large loads For firm energy: no holder identified. For hedge capacity: the Economic Regulator administers the rule S137 No published ranking of competing large loads for firm energy in any document. A documented pro-rata rule exists for hedge capacity, floored at 4.3–5.6 MW a quarter. The question stops being answerable at all
13 The House's call for a moratorium on new AI and data centres over 5 MW S165 The Government, to enact it; or the Minister for Planning, by an interim amendment to the State Planning Provisions Passed 17–13 on 18 November S170; no statutory effect; refused by a government spokesperson the next day S177. Nothing: a resolution is repeatable, and its effect is exhausted when the House rises
14 Data Centre Safeguards Bill 2026 (54 of 2026) S166 House of Assembly, then the Legislative Council First reading 17 November; Government opposed; not passed. Its commencement date. Applications already lodged and Panels already established are exempt; permits already granted survive but cannot be extended.
15 Commencement of any statutory or planning prohibition Governor in Executive Council, or Parliament Not commenced. Each of the bill's two end-conditions is itself an executive instrument. The interval in which a proponent can lodge an application, have a Panel established, execute supply and connection, and commence work under an existing permit

Why entry 12 is the one that matters

Eleven of these decisions change a term: a price, a condition, a date. Entry 12 changes what the work can say. If there is no published ranking of competing large loads for firm energy, then the question of who gets the state's firm capacity — and on what basis — has no answer in the record, and no amount of further research will produce one. That absence is the finding, and it is not repaired by a decision going one way or the other.

The interval

Between a motion and an Act there is an interval, and in that interval a proponent can lodge, contract and begin. The 18 November resolution created no legal effect; the bill's exemptions are defined by what exists when it commences. Everything that can be lodged, agreed or begun before that date sits outside the prohibition it proposes.

That is the asymmetry worth watching. The instruments that stop things are prospective and slow. The instruments that commit things — a supply contract, a connection agreement, a permit already granted — are immediate, and they outlive the debate.